Having an Honest Conversation About Relationship Agreements
Two men have been dating for four months. They spend most weekends together, have met each other’s friends, and recently started calling each other boyfriends. One has stopped using dating apps. He figured that was part of becoming a couple. The other still opens an app occasionally and has been expecting them to talk about exclusivity when they’re ready. Then a friend asks how long they’ve been exclusive, and both men realize they would give different answers.
The conversation that follows can feel like it’s about an app, a word, or who should have brought it up first. Underneath is a more important question. What have we actually agreed to, and do we both want it?
For gay, bisexual, and other men who date men, the assumptions can come from several directions. One man may have grown up thinking that a serious relationship automatically means sexual exclusivity. His partner may know several long-term couples who are open and see the structure of a relationship as something people decide together. Either man may find himself agreeing quickly because he likes where things are going and fears that an honest answer will bring it all to an end.
A relationship agreement asks both people to say what they want, hear what their partner wants, and decide what they can genuinely agree to. Some couples know fairly early. For others, it takes more than one conversation, especially when they’re still figuring out what the words mean to each of them.
Ask What He Means by Monogamous or Open
“Are we exclusive?” sounds like a question with an easy yes or no answer. But one man may hear it as a question about sex, while the other hears it as a question about flirting, dating apps, private messages, and emotional involvement. They can say yes at exactly the same time and walk away with different expectations.
The word open leaves just as much room for interpretation. One partner may picture occasional sex with someone else while traveling. The other may want the freedom to see the same person more than once or go on dates that could develop into something ongoing. One may want to hear about outside encounters beforehand. His partner may feel comfortable sharing information that affects them both while keeping intimate details private.
Start with situations you can picture. “When you say you’d like us to be exclusive, what would that mean for the apps we still use?” can help you understand what your partner is asking for. If he says he wants to open the relationship, “What do you imagine being able to do that you can’t do now?” gives him space to describe a real desire. He might be asking for something more specific, or more uncertain, than you heard in the word open.
You can also ask where your own expectations came from. Maybe the couples you admire happen to be monogamous. Maybe the first gay couple you knew who seemed to have a lasting, happy relationship was openly non-monogamous. Those examples may have helped you imagine a future for yourself. You and your partner still get to decide which parts of that future you want to share.
Say What You Want Before You Try to Compromise
Sometimes the first thing you say in a relationship conversation is the safest version of what you feel. “I could probably do monogamy” may mean “I’m afraid you’ll think I can’t commit if I say I want an open relationship.” “I could be open to that” may mean “I think you’re going to leave if I ask for exclusivity.” On the surface, both men sound flexible. Each may be trying very hard to keep the relationship.
If you can, give your partner a clearer account of where you are. “I want us to be sexually exclusive. I’ve thought about openness, and right now I’d be agreeing mainly because I don’t want to lose you.” Or, “I care about you and want to build a life with you. I also want the freedom to have sex with other people, and I don’t know whether I can be happy promising exclusivity.” Both statements can be hard to hear. They give your partner information he needs before he can make a choice of his own.
Uncertainty is worth expressing just as clearly. You may know you want to stay with your boyfriend but have no idea how you’d feel if he went home with someone else. You may like the idea of monogamy and wonder whether it’s something you actively want or something you’ve always expected yourself to choose. “I don’t know yet” can be an honest answer, even after you’ve been together for years.
Try to hear a preference before interpreting it as a verdict on the relationship. If your partner wants monogamy, he may be telling you about the kind of commitment he wants to make and receive. If he wants openness, he may be describing a way he can imagine committing to you. You can ask what commitment would look like in daily life. His answer might involve how you show up for each other when work gets difficult, how you protect time together, or what you tell each other when feelings change. Those details help you understand what each of you hopes to preserve.
Give Each Other Room to Say No
A man can have butterflies about an agreement he genuinely wants to try. He can also sound completely calm while agreeing to something he dreads. Pay attention to how much freedom both of you have to answer honestly.
Imagine your boyfriend brings up opening the relationship. You say you’re unsure, and he responds with “I thought you were more secure than that.” The next time he asks, you say yes. He may be relieved to have an answer, while you’re relieved that the argument is over. A similar dynamic can happen around exclusivity. If you tell him that anyone who really loved you would gladly be monogamous, he may give you the promise you want before he’s had a chance to think about whether he can keep it.
A direct statement about compatibility can sound similar from a distance and feel very different up close. “I need a monogamous relationship, and I understand you may want something else” gives your partner a real answer about what you can offer. “If you loved me, you’d agree” asks him to prove his feelings by giving you the answer you want. You can say your preference matters enough that it may affect whether you stay together. Then give him the time and space to decide what that means for him.
If you’re the one who proposed a change, pay attention when your partner says “Fine,” especially if he’s spent the previous half hour telling you he feels uneasy. You can ask, “If we left things as they are for now, how would you feel?” and hear him out. You might discover that he needs time to think, that he has a specific concern you can talk through, or that he’s been trying to find a gentler way to tell you no.
If you’re the one who said yes to keep things from falling apart, you can go back to the conversation. “I said I was okay with it because I was scared you’d leave. I’ve realized I can’t keep acting like we reached a decision I feel good about.” Your partner may feel surprised or disappointed, especially if he took your earlier answer in good faith. Give him a chance to respond. You’re both better placed to decide what happens next when he knows how you actually feel.
Agree on What Happens While You’re Still Deciding
Suppose you’ve been exclusive for two years and one of you asks whether you’d consider opening the relationship. The conversation may take several weeks. During that time, you can discuss the idea, ask questions, and even change your minds about which parts appeal to you. Your existing agreement still applies until you both agree to change it.
If you’re dating and have never talked about exclusivity, the situation calls for a different conversation. One of you may want to pause seeing other people while you decide. The other may feel comfortable continuing to date and telling you that honestly. You can make a temporary agreement if you both want one. You can also decide how much time you’re willing to spend in a situation where you want different things. A mutually chosen date to revisit the conversation can spare you both the uncertainty of wondering whether it will ever come up again.
Make any interim agreement specific enough to follow. “Let’s keep things exclusive through the end of the month and talk on Sunday about what we’re each thinking” means more than “Let’s just see how we feel.” It gives you a chance to notice your feelings without scrutinizing every evening your boyfriend spends out with friends. When Sunday comes, either of you may still be unsure. Say so, and decide together whether extending the arrangement feels right for both of you.
Put the Agreement Into Everyday Language
Once you agree on a broad structure, talk about the situations most likely to matter in your own lives. For a monogamous couple, that might mean discussing what each of you considers sexual or romantic contact outside the relationship. A dating app, a flirty conversation with an ex, or an exchange of intimate photos may carry very different meanings to two people. You can respect each other’s friendships and privacy while being clear about the conduct you’re agreeing to.
For an open couple, it might mean discussing how much notice you want to give each other, how you’ll handle overnights, or how you’ll talk about sexual health and changes that affect each other’s choices. If one of you wants a heads-up about a date, ask what knowing beforehand would do for him. He may want time to make his own plans so he’s less likely to spend the evening waiting for a message. His partner may worry that a request for notice will become a request for permission every time he goes out. Talking through an ordinary Friday night can reveal that difference faster than debating what open should mean.
Be honest about what you can realistically promise. Outside partners have privacy and feelings of their own. If you want to tell your boyfriend that you spent the evening with someone, you can share what affects your agreement without assuming you have permission to pass along the other person’s private details. And if you agree to tell each other when a casual connection starts to feel emotionally important, it helps to say what would prompt that conversation. Wanting to see the same man every week may be something worth bringing up even if you’re still figuring out what you feel.
The agreement should also leave you a way to talk about surprises. Maybe you thought you would prefer knowing every detail and discover you only want the information that affects you. Maybe you agreed that casual flirting was fine until a particular exchange makes you wonder whether the two of you meant the same thing. Bring up what happened and what you understood the agreement to be. From there, you can work out whether one of you broke a promise or whether you both need to get clearer about what you promised in the first place.
Let the Agreement Change Through Conversation
Preferences can change. A man who liked being open when he and his boyfriend lived in different cities may want exclusivity after they move in together. A man who once felt sure about monogamy may become curious about another arrangement. A couple can also change one part of an agreement and keep the rest. Wanting fewer late-night interruptions to your time together may be a conversation about phones at dinner, even if it first comes up in a discussion about dating apps.
If you want to make a change, bring it up while your partner still has a meaningful choice. Tell him what’s changed for you and what you’re asking him to consider. Give him the chance to tell you about what the current agreement means to him. He may have built a sense of trust around it, and he may need time to understand what your request would mean for his life.
You may discover that both of you still want the same kind of relationship once you’ve worked through the details. You may discover that you want different things and that neither can comfortably offer what the other needs. There can be grief in that, especially when you still love the man you’re talking to. Being able to say so gives you both the dignity of deciding with the truth in front of you.
A few months after that awkward conversation with their friend, the two men at the beginning of this article could be monogamous, open, or still working it out. In any of those cases, they can ask each other the same question in a quiet moment at home. “How are you feeling about what we agreed to?” What matters is that each man can answer in his own words, even on a day when the answer is difficult to hear.
